From: Kevin Kelly <kkelly@rrnet.com>
Reply-To: kkelly@rrnet.com
Organization: Forever Healthy
Subject: Re: Colloidal minerals
This reply is lengthy, but I think people will find it interesting.
I am a Licensed Registered Dietitian. Nutrition fraud is something I
follow closely. All of this talk about colloidal minerals and most of
the rest of this vitamin/mineral hype is just that. The claims are
numerous and usually ridiculous. For example, one tape entitled "Dead
Doctors Don't Lie" sounds convincing, but is so bogus. This guy takes
simple facts and builds a fictitious story around them. He claims
that cystic fibrosis can be cured by taking a vitamin or mineral. (I
forget which one). Cystic fibrosis is inherited and is not caused by
a nutritional deficiency. This is just one example of how his tape
sounds convincing, but is wrong. I have easily picked apart his tape
and there isn't room to do so here.
He is appealing to what the public wants: health in a bottle. It
doesn't exist. Responsible health professionals (physicians, nurses,
dietitians, chirporactors, etc) will tell you the best thing you can
do for your health is to have good dietary habits and a regular
exercise program. Good health takes effort. But, many people want to
take the easy way out - which doesn't exist - when it comes to losing
weight, preventive health, etc. and the quacks pushing the
misinformation and bogus products know it. Just follow the money
trail. Quacks push products that are glitzy, glamourous, and offer
instant gratification. That appeals to many people.
It is easy to fool people who are looking for the quick fix. I had a
lady call me recently. Her neighbor lost weight taking a certain
product. Substitute a shake for breakfast and lunch then have a light
supper was the plan. I told the lady I have a better product that
will cause quicker weight loss. It is called tap water. She asked
how it works. The shake has about 200 calories and water has no
calories. She asked if the water in her tap will be good enough. I
said no because I have the only source of this special water in North
Dakota. I sell it for $10.00 a bottle. Then she caught on. I was
feeding her a line. Bottom line: people lose weight because they
take in fewer calories than their bodies need. It is not the prodcut
(or a food) that causes weight loss, but many people don't realize
that.
People claim they feel better after taking a product. If there is a
true nutritional deficiency, a supplement may help. Besides, a
diagnosis is needed by a physician to determine a true deficiency. I
look at many food records and many people are deficient in calcium.
That doesn't mean they have osteoporosis. Yes, it could happen in the
future. Calcium is involved in muscle contraction. Even though these
people lack adequate amounts of calcium in the diet, their muscles
still work. Most people who feel better are almost always
experiencing a placebo effect. I know of situations where a certain
nutritional product, which has no benefit, was given to several
people. The power of suggestion is very convincing. Mind over matter
is very real.
I need to respond to an anticipated question. I do believe in
supplementation. Not everyone needs it and there are definitely
situations that call for it. A good example is a vegan or a person
lacking calcium in the diet. The problem with supplementation is the
irresponsible way it is being promoted, all in the interest of money.
These people pushing misinformation and bogus products are nothing
more than quacks. They are committing fraud by bilking people
(especially the elderly and people desperate to lose weight, etc) out
of their money. Would you go to a plumber to have your teeth worked
on? Would you let a carpener fix you car? Why trust your nutritional
needs to someone whose nutritional background is inadequate? Most
people who sell this garbage are armed with only the information in a
brochure and from a weekend rally.
For whatever it's worth, most of these products are harmless.
However, vitamins and minerals can have side effects in large doeses.
I have seen some of the side effects. In addition, taking large
doeses of one vitamin/mineral can interfere with the absorption of
other vitamin/minerals. Self-diagnosis is also not a good idea. It
is interesting that people who want good health will take chances with
supplements that they know nothing about, let alone the person who is
selling it to them.
Kevin Kelly, Licensed Registered Dietitan